Will Language Learning Become Obsolete? A Personal Reflection
The idea that language learning might become obsolete is one of those predictions that sparks excitement, fear, and a lot of debate.
Given the rapid development of translation technology – from Google Translate to AI-powered devices – some people, including myself, wonder if tech is making learning foreign languages obsolete.
But is that really the case? As a linguist, I find this question both intriguing and unsettling. Let me guide you through my considerations on this topic and let’s see if technology can truly replace the practice of learning a language.
Translation Technology
Translating Then and Translating Today
It is undoubtable that translation technology has evolved in the last decade. I remember using clunky, inaccurate tools for my school homework not too long ago, and now we have apps and devices that can instantly translate spoken language in real-time.
It was 2019, I was living in Russia when I met a Chinese guy. He spoke no English, but we managed to communicate thanks to the then-brand-new Google Translate setting that allowed to speak and instantly translate. Now, this is an everyday activity, but only six years ago, I was shocked by it!
Although these tools have evolved, they’re not flawless. If you ever used Google Translate aiming at obtaining a nuanced conversation, I am sure you felt disappointed at least once.
Words are often mistranslated, idioms are often misunderstood, and the emotional undertones get lost. Even with AI advancements, technology still struggles with context and cultural subtleties.
For instance, translating the Italian idiom in bocca al lupo as “in the mouth of the wolf” doesn’t capture the aim of wishing someone good luck, as you would do with the English “break a leg”.
Translation Tech is a Tool, Not a Replacement
From my experience, translation technology can be a helpful tool, especially for travelers or in emergency situations. But let’s be clear: translations tech is a tool, not a replacement.
Language is not just about words, it’s about connection, culture, and understanding the human experience from a different perspective. For example, how can you truly understand the Italian culture without knowing the meaning behind the expressions magari?
This perspective caught my attention when I read a discussion on Reddit on whether language learning will become obsolete.
Most users expressed skepticism about technology’s ability to replace language learning entirely and argued that, despite the advancements, technologies are still far from grasping the complexities and nuances of human language.
To be honest, I totally agree with them! Especially in the most recent days, with the promise of Neuralink as the future of communication and learning, some might wonder if these innovations could revolutionize how we perceive languages.
The True Value of Language Learning
Language learning goes beyond mere translation. When you learn a language, you gain insight into how people think, feel, and see the world. This helps explain the idea that you behave differently when you speak a different language.
Think of all those Italian words that have no equivalent in English: the word abbiocco, for example, describes the sleepy sensation that follows a large meal, something that the English translation “food coma” doesn’t fully capture.
This understanding adds depth to communication that no AI can replicate.
Why you Should not Fully Rely on Technology
Cognitive and Social Benefits
Multilingualism comes with cognitive benefits that technology simply can’t replicate. Studies show that learning a language improves memory, problem-solving skills, and even multitasking abilities. It also delays the onset of cognitive decline.
Moreover, there’s a unique social aspect: language classes, meetups, or even simple and random conversations with native speakers force us out of our comfort zones and foster human connections.
For instance, imagine the joy of understanding a joke in Italian or finally feeling confident ordering food in a market in Rome is irreplaceable. Could a device ever provide that feeling? I doubt it.
The Limitations of Technology
Imagine this scenario: you’re in a remote village in Italy, and your app suddenly stops working due to no internet connection. You’re left with the basic Italian basic vocabulary you learned in movies and body language.
Also, language is fluid and dynamic, constantly evolving with slang, new expressions, and cultural trends. AI struggles to keep up with these changes.
The Future of Language Learning
I know it is tempting to think that we’re moving towards a future where we’ll no longer need to learn languages, but, for me, the reality is more complex.
Translation technology will undoubtedly continue to improve, but it will never fully replicate the experience, benefits, and richness of learning a language.
Language learning is mainly about the human experience: the joy of discovery, the satisfaction of progress, and the beauty of connecting across cultures.
So, will language learning become obsolete? I’d say it’s just the opposite. As technology makes the world more accessible, the value of deep, meaningful human connections will increase even more.
And there’s no better way to connect than by speaking someone’s language.
دیدگاهتان را بنویسید